Angi, Thumbtack or your own website: which is better for snow removal leads?
Lead services like Angi, Thumbtack and HomeAdvisor promise calls without the hassle of marketing. Sometimes they deliver. Here's how they compare with your own website, so you can decide with your eyes open.
How lead sites work
A homeowner asks for snow removal quotes. The lead site sends that request to several companies at once, and each one pays for it. Whoever calls back first usually wins.
Good
- Calls can start right away
- No website needed
Not so good
- You pay per lead, whether you win the job or not
- The same lead often goes to your competitors
- Stop paying and the calls stop
- The customer belongs to the platform as much as to you
How your own website works
Someone searches "snow removal [your town]", finds your site, and calls you. Nobody else gets that lead.
Good
- Every call is yours alone, at no cost per lead
- It keeps working after you've paid for it
- You build your own name, not the platform's
Not so good
- It can take a few weeks to show up well on Google, so it's slower to start than buying leads
- It works best with a Google Business Profile and a few reviews behind it
The math
If a lead site charges you $15 to $40 a lead and you close 1 in 3, each new customer costs you about $45 to $120, every time. A $595 site that brings in even a handful of seasonal customers a year costs less per customer, and those customers called only you.
So which should you use?
- Just starting, or need calls this week? A lead site can bridge the gap.
- Want customers you don't pay for twice? Get your own site. Many operators use both for a season, then drop the lead site once their own calls are steady.
Want to see your site before you decide?
Tell us your business name and towns, and we'll build a preview of your site before you pay anything. See the snow removal websites page Or call or text Joe at (608) 214-9123.

